🧨 No Secrets, No Exceptions: Why Children Should Never Be Asked to Keep Secrets From Their Families

U

At RosasChildren, we teach one simple truth:
Any adult who encourages a child to keep a secret from their parent or guardian is not safe.

It doesn’t matter how kind they seem.
It doesn’t matter how trusted the institution is.
It doesn’t matter what the secret is about.

🚨 “Don’t Tell Your Mom, It’ll Just Upset Her.”

This kind of language is a red flag—not a small one. A major one.

Even when the topic seems harmless…
Even when it’s framed as “supportive”…
Even when the adult sounds compassionate, understanding, or progressive…

Secret-keeping is how predators operate.

🧠 Let’s Be Clear: There Is No Reliable Test for “Good Intentions”

People who encourage secrecy with children often present as:

• Friendly

• Sincere

• Soft-spoken

• Empathetic

• “Safer” than the parent

But there is no objective test for what’s in someone’s heart.
There’s only behavior.
There’s only boundaries.
There’s only the question: “Why would you need to hide this from a loving parent?”

If the answer relies on secrecy, that adult is stepping outside the bounds of trust.

🚫 It Is Never the Role of a School, Faith Institution, or Club to Teach Children to Keep Secrets from Their Family

Even if it’s framed as:

• “Protecting the child’s privacy”

• “Giving them space”

• “Letting them figure things out”

• “Supporting their identity or feelings”

If it involves saying “Don’t tell your family,”
It has already crossed the line.

Parents and guardians have a right to know what’s being said, shared, and suggested to their children. Especially when those children are still developing, still vulnerable, and still forming their sense of safety and truth.

🧱 Families Are the First Circle of Safety.

• A child’s relationship with their caregiver should never be undermined.

• No adult—no matter how well-meaning they seem—should insert themselves between a child and their trusted adult.

It’s not their child.
It’s not their place.
It’s not safe.

✅ What Safe Adults Do Instead:

• They encourage openness with families.

• They ask, “Have you talked to your parents about this?”

• They offer support without secrecy.

• They understand that a strong parent-child relationship is not a threat—it’s a gift.

At RosasChildren, we trust your instincts.
If something feels off, it probably is.
You don’t need permission to protect your child.
You don’t need to explain your boundaries.
And you should never have to compete with another adult for your child’s trust.

There is no such thing as “just a small secret.”
There are no exceptions when it comes to child safety.